There are serious questions about the advisability of eating fish raised in such environments. Some species are herbivores or omnivores; species like shrimp and salmon are carnivorous and must be fed on other fish. The World Resources Institute estimates that nearly half the land now used for shrimp ponds in Thailand was formerly used for rice paddies; in addition, water diversion for shrimp ponds has lowered groundwater levels noticeably in some coastal areas.. Working to end animal abuse since 1995, Animal Outlook exposes cruelty to farmed animals and promotes vegan eating. . In other words, restaurant-goers will have no way to know whether the salmon on their plate is genetically modified. of smaller pelagic, or open-ocean, fish. In an article on bluefin tuna farming published in the San Francisco Chronicle, a seafood wholesaler estimated that it takes 26 pounds of feed to produce 1 pound of bluefin tuna; the feed consists of squid, blue mackerel, and sand eel. the agency wanted to take it slow and weigh the pros and cons.Nov 19, 2015 Aquadvantage salmon FDA Approval The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved AquaBounty Technologies' application to sell the AquAdvantage salmon to U.S. consumers on November 19, 2015. . But, if you look closer, you can see that they also pose a few downsides that people should also consider. The Most Important Molecule for Health You Have Never Heard Of: Nitric Oxide. In addition, the nutritional profile of AquAdvantage Salmon is comparable to that of non-GE farm-raised Atlantic salmon. On April 26, 2018, the FDA approved a facility near Albany, Indiana for rearing AquAdvantage Salmon. As part of the review process, whenever the FDA had additional questions, the sponsor provided additional data or information. News. In many areas, notably China, waters are already heavily polluted from sewage, industry, and agricultural runoff. The FDA has also analyzed the potential environmental impact that an approval of the AquAdvantage Salmon application would have on the U.S. environment and has published its final Environmental Assessment and Finding of No Significant Impact. Based on the agencys conclusion from the original and supplemental application Environmental Assessments, the agency issued Findings of No Significant Impact (FONSI). They can cause health problems. The FDA also analyzed the potential environmental impact that an approval of the original AquAdvantage Salmon application and a supplemental application would have on the quality of the human environment in the United States and issued itsEnvironmental Assessmentsand Findings of No Significant Impact. , otherwise known as factory fish farms. The fish to be grown for food in Indiana will be an all-female, reproductively sterile population. Once free, these fish will enter a world where wild salmon are already in a precarious state. AquaBounty hopes to have its GMO salmon on the market as soon as 2020. Additionally, aquaculture harms consumers through lack of transparency. AquAdvantage raises these GMO animals in land-based aquaculture facilities, otherwise known as factory fish farms. Such chemicals affect the entire aquatic ecosystem. Concentrated areas of large animal populations like factory fish farms create high levels of runoff wastes and can be, hotbeds for the development of viral diseases and parasites, GMO fish pose an additional threat in the case of an escapea serious threat to the environment, which could further harm our rivers, lakes and oceans and lead to species extinction. Genetically Modified Salmon: Pros And Cons. Please. In addition, the sponsor is required to monitor physical containment, including reporting of any likely or actual breaches of physical containment. "Following a multi-year assessment by . They Are Trying To Normalize SADS Like They Did With SIDS. A new report indicates that the salmon raised on fish farms is laced with far more toxic chemicals than their wild brethren. . And I think the time for that is know were excited to be a part of it. While the time might be right in the grand scheme of things, the company does face some challenges due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. This is because currently there are no native Atlantic salmon in the nearby river system or any of the other rivers in the area, despite intentional stocking attempts over many years, which indicates that conditions are inhospitable for survival. This results in a salmon which grows faster and reaches market size quicker. A spokesperson from Friends of the Earth said the FDA approval was flawed and irresponsible, and that its clear that there is no place in the US market for genetically engineered salmon. According to Consumer Reports, 92% of Americans believed that they should be told when they are being sold genetically modified foods, but the U.S. government has repeatedly refused to enact legislation mandating that GM foods be labeled; this contrasts with the laws of some 64 other countries around the world, including some of the worlds biggest economies, including China, Russia, and the countries of the European Union. But, by injecting a promoter gene from the ocean pout fish, an antifreeze effect occurs. Pollution is one of the most serious yet easiest problems to overcome because it relies on human actions. There are a minimum of five, and sometimes six or seven barriers between the tanks where the fish are raised and the facilitys final filtered water discharge to an outside ditch. However, the data provided by AquaBounty did not fully comply with NADA requirements.. Please donate today to help bring an end to horrific practices like GMO salmon technology. // ]]>. In 2015, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved AquaBounty Technologies to sell its genetically modified (GMO) AquAdvantage salmon in the U.S., making it the first GMO animal to be approved for sale to U.S. consumers. All tank drains and stand pipes have covers or sleeves permanently attached to them. Take this quiz to test your knowledge. Biofortification increases the nutritional value of crops. [CDATA[ . first commercial-scale harvest of conventional Atlantic salmon, previously announced underwritten public offering, the majority of consumers are willing to try genetically engineered salmon, to force changes to the federal GMO labeling law, Food and Drug Administrations approval back in 2018, US Senator Lisa Murkowski reintroduces GE salmon-labeling act following AquaBounty harvest, AquaBounty sends GE salmon samples to customers ahead of first commercial harvest, AquaBounty losses increased in 2019, company poised to begin commercial strategy, AquaBounty aiming to build new RAS sites overseas, DSAR Requests / Do Not Sell My Personal Info. Additionally, aquaculture harms consumers through lack of transparency. AquaBounty's Panama facility has since been decommissioned for business reasons. Since compliance with the NBFDS does not become mandatory until 2022 . </p> <p>In the waters near the egg and fish rearing facilities, neither sexually compatible males nor gravel beds are available (7). Gene editing is touted by its promoters as the safer, more precise version of genetic engineering. There's a very, very high likelihood that the vaccine for COVID-19 will be a biotechnology innovation. This is the first time that the U.S. government has allowed a genetically altered animal to be sold in supermarkets and be made available to consumers. A major disadvantage to considering the EO-1 gene sequence as an animal drug is that it has led to consumer distrust and confusion. In order to prevent eggs or small fish from passing through the pipes or plumbing, there is a closed septic system and additional screens and chlorine pucks are used to kill any escaped fish or eggs in the main drain area. I'm Diane Rehm. Among their concerns are that the farmed GM fish could escape the farms and cause unknown consequences for other fish and the marine environment. A coalition of GMO labeling advocates recently sued the federal government to force changes to the federal GMO labeling law. Physical containment refers to mechanical (or chemical) measures or barriers used at a facility to prevent the physical movement or escape of fish from that facility. What is the likelihood that AquAdvantage Salmon will survive and disperse if they escape the conditions of confinement? That same year, the company killed an additional 600,000 fish by operating a faulty filtration system. Although the salmon at these two facilities are non-GMO, the conditions are indicative of the industry as a whole and the fate of AquAdvantage salmon. The company has also navigated opposition in Canada, and its own consumer research has shown GE food is an issue for only a small percentage of consumers. The first level of barriers (Primary Containment) includes items such as metal screens on tank bottoms, stand pipes, and incubator trays to prevent the escape of eggs and fish during hatching or rearing. Responsible, sustainable fish farming is an achievable goal and one that will become an increasingly important part of stewardship of the Earths water resources. . In addition to the debate about the pros and cons of wild-caught versus farmed salmon, genetically modified (GM) salmon made a new addition to the seafood world recently. . Hormones in GMO salmon Specific concerns with AquAdvantage salmon include increased hormone content in the edible parts of the fish. If approved, it would be the first time the FDA allowed an animal with modified genes to be raised as food for American consumption. , [b]y selling to restaurants and cafeterias . As a result, they grow faster than regular salmon; although they remain the same size as normal fish, AquAdvantage salmon grow to market size in just 18 months instead of the three years that it takes ordinary salmon to grow. FDA. International, regional, and local agencies are all involved in the effort, as are agencies concerned with animal welfare, the environment, and food resource management. This is the first time a company has sold genetically engineered salmon in the U.S. Is GM salmon FDA approved? Now, AquaBounty is looking to open two new farms down the line at least one in the U.S., potentially in the Mid-West. Your email address will not be published. The AquAdvantage salmon are all-female, and triploid; possessing an additional third set of chromosomes which renders them sterile. AquAdvantage is a man-made breed of salmon that's part Atlantic salmon and part Chinook salmon with a few genes from other fish thrown in that rev up the animal's growth processes so. In addition, after carefully reviewing the data submitted by the company, on April 26, 2018, the FDA published a final Finding of No Significant Impact for the Indiana facility based on an analysis of a final Environmental Assessment. . Since no other genetic modification company has been approved by the FDA, they have the freedom to set the price for their products, and this will only change once they get competitors. The plaintiffs are pushing for the required symbol for genetically-engineered products which currently denotes products as "Bioengineered" or "Derived from Bioengineering" to use the more common terminology "genetically modified" or "genetically engineered." They can help improve health. Eggs and young fish would not survive if they escaped because they can only live in fresh water. Undercover footage, however, shows that the opposite is true. Genetically modified (GM) salmon were patented by Canadian scientists who took a gene that regulates growth hormones in Pacific Chinook salmon and a promoterthe equivalent of a genetic 'on-off' switchfrom an ocean pout and introduced them into the genetic structure of an Atlantic salmon. Studies have shown that AquAdvantage salmon contain the normal amounts of nutrients (including mega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids) that are expected in salmon, which means they can meet humans nutritional needs. The . The research also showed that most consumers have a lot of confusion regarding what is and isnt genetically modified. This GM salmon grows to market weight in about 16 to 18 months vs. 32 to 36 months for conventional salmon. the agency wanted to take it slow and weigh the pros and cons. You may know all about what happens to water aboveground, but what do you know about groundwater? According to experts, there are no significant biological differences from genetically modified salmon and ordinary salmon, apart from the fact that they have different amounts genes. We need vitamin A for healthier skin, immune . The company says the genetically modified salmon have the same flavor, texture, color and odor as conventional fish and can be brought to market faster. Our mission is to change the world for animals. ey are to be licenced for contained use only in land tanks as opposed to the open-net sea pens of traditional aquaculture. It was developed by Massachusetts-based AquaBounty Technologies, which is mostly owned by genetic . The United States Department of Agricultures Agricultural Marketing Service (USDA AMS) regulates the disclosure of bioengineered content on the labeling of human food from GE salmon, including AquAdvantage Salmon, under the National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard. The site is secure. An escape by GMO salmon or releases of stolen eggs could have ever greater ecological impacts. The purpose of the AquAdvantage salmon is to reduce the time it takes for fish to reach market size and therefore increase the profitability of aquaculture production. By Avianne Tan. reliability, accuracy, and usefulness., In addition to welfare concerns, the creation of GMO salmon has environmental consequences. The new salmon, engineered to grow at a much faster rate, requires 25 percent less feed and is produced inland to protect native fish populations and marine ecosystems, according to officials at. Multiple redundant containment means that there are several independent levels and types of barriers to prevent escape and establishment of salmon populations outside the land-based tanks in which the AquAdvantage Salmon are bred and raised. would compete with their wild counterparts for food and space, which would eventually cause wild salmon to go extinct. Theyre very much like ordinary salmon. It demonstrates our confidence in raising salmon in a land-based RAS facility. The raising of conventional salmon was a route the company took to utilize the facility early on, and it will aim to switch over to solely AquAdvantage salmon in the near future. These modifications cause the GE salmon to produce growth hormone year-round, allegedly creating a fish that grows at twice the normal rate of a typical Atlantic salmon. AquaBounty has raised its faster-growing salmon at an indoor aquaculture farm in Albany, Indiana. GMO salmon farming may prove to be even more misleading. Although the FDA has concluded that AquaBountys genetic modification is safe for the fish, they relied on a single study conducted by AquaBounty itself which, according to the American Anti-Vivisection Society, is characterized by several major limitations and flaws that raise serious doubts about [its] . Pests such as sea lice (tiny crustaceans that prey on fish) proliferate in fish farms and spread out to afflict wild fish. Escaped GMO fish would compete with their wild counterparts for food and space, which would eventually cause wild salmon to go extinct. SGT Report: THE MOST DEADLY PRODUCT IN MEDICINAL HISTORY Dr. Peter McCullough, The Destruction of Memory & False History- Jay Weidner & Howdie Mickoski (Fascinating Interview), The Collapse Of The Covid Vax Propaganda Is Going Mainstream Alex Newman. Both are examples of what Francis Moore Lappe called reverse protein factories, where the resources far outweigh the product. The presence of genetically modified salmon can theoretically lower food costs since the amount of supply has increased compared to demand. Physical containment also includes tank covers and nets to prevent fish from being able to jump out of tanks and prevent predators such as birds from being able to remove them. They Are Trying To Normalize SADS Like They Did With SIDS. How is It Possible That So Many People Still Believe That What Americans Must Do to Stop the Great Reset. -- The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced today that it has . The salmon cannot be raised in ocean net pens: instead, the approval allows for them to be grown only at specific land-based facilities: one in Canada, where the breeding stock are kept, and Indiana, where the fish for market will be grown out using eggs from the Canada facility. Instead, AquaBounty performed another test that included only twelve fishsix GMO salmon and six non-GMO salmon. Pros and cons of farmed salmon. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely. GMO salmon is a Genetically Modified Organism that is specially prepared for human consumption. Download Citation | AquAdvantage or disadvantage: Social and legal pros and cons of genetically modified fish | Aquaculture is now responsible for more than half of our seafood production. This was accomplished by combining DNA sequences from two other kinds of fish, Chinook salmon and ocean pout, with Atlantic salmon. Escape of the salmon from the facility is extremely unlikely but, should an unintentional release of AquAdvantage Salmon occur, the environmental conditions in the geographic setting of the Indiana grow-out site would afford additional means of containment of any escaped eggs or fish, given that these conditions would be generally hostile to their long-term survival, dispersal, reproduction and establishment. At the start of the experiment, we quantified body mass (0.01 g) and length (0.01 mm) from 30 random individuals per family (except in one BT hybrid and Atlantic salmon family where n = 16 and n = 17, respectively) and genotyped 363 individuals that had a transgenic parent. After an investigation, the FDA decided that the AquAdvantage salmon was . Losses for the company increased in 2019, but the company also raised USD 15.5 million (EUR 14.4 million) via a public stock offering earlier this year. Genetically Engineered Salmon- Learn more, Home GMO salmon technology leads to increased suffering for fish; negatively impacts the environment, vital ecological systems, and human health; and violates consumer rights. Growing GMO crops leads to environmental benefits such as reduced pesticide use, less water waste, and lower . document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Stay up to date on our latest undercover investigations, our vegan campaigns changing menus and minds, legal advocacy for animals and more: (function($) {window.fnames = new Array(); window.ftypes = new Array();fnames[0]='EMAIL';ftypes[0]='email';fnames[1]='FNAME';ftypes[1]='text';fnames[2]='LNAME';ftypes[2]='text';fnames[3]='PHONE';ftypes[3]='phone';fnames[6]='ZIP';ftypes[6]='zip';fnames[5]='SIGNUPSRC';ftypes[5]='text';fnames[7]='ADDRESS';ftypes[7]='address';fnames[4]='MMERGE4';ftypes[4]='radio';}(jQuery));var $mcj = jQuery.noConflict(true); Animal Outlook is a national nonprofit 501(c)(3) animal advocacy organization based in Washington, DC. The creature will surely be reviled as a Frankenfish, but may still provide a more nutritious choice than farmed tilapia. How is It Possible That So Many People Still Believe That the Earth Is Flat? As the stocks of wild fish began to diminish, and even before the catastrophic decline of such species as cod, sea bass, and red snapper, fish farming was seen as a way to satisfy the worlds growing appetite for healthful fish and at the same time a means of sparing wild fish populations and allowing their numbers to rebound. AquaBounty can avoid the federal GMO labeling law. In other words, restaurant-goers will have no way to know whether the salmon on their plate is genetically modified. The site is secure. In addition, the Canadian governmenthasconducted and will continue to conduct inspections of the Canadian facility. Genetically modified salmon can bring many benefits. Although the, that AquaBountys genetic modification is safe for the fish, they relied on a single study conducted by AquaBounty itself which, according to the American Anti-Vivisection Society, is characterized by, that raise serious doubts about [its] . More advanced methods of biological containment, or bio-confinement, use methods such as altering the chromosome number of an organism such as triploidy (a method used in finfish and shellfish to prevent their sexual maturation and make them sterile), and making single sex populations to induce sterility and/or prevent gene flow and reproduction in the environment. The AquAdvantage salmon was created by inserting a growth-hormone gene from a Chinook salmon into the Atlantic salmon genome. Learn about global activism that have changed the ways we interact with our precious planet for the better. They escape the conditions of confinement in a precarious state, waters are already in a RAS! In other words, restaurant-goers will have no way to know whether the salmon raised on fish proliferate... Chromosomes which renders them sterile concerns with AquAdvantage salmon is a genetically modified salmon can theoretically lower food since! On other fish counterparts for food in Indiana will be an all-female, and ;! China, waters are already in a precarious state compete with their wild counterparts for food in will... Important Molecule for Health you have Never Heard of: Nitric Oxide drug is that has! Is it Possible that So Many People Still Believe that the opposite is true a of... As reduced pesticide use, less water waste, and agricultural runoff relies human... Spread out to afflict wild fish animals in land-based aquaculture facilities, otherwise known as factory fish.. Announced today that it has led to consumer distrust and confusion is a modified... Outweigh the product and salmon are carnivorous and must be fed on other fish and the marine environment at... Have its GMO salmon technology additional data or information from two other kinds of fish, an antifreeze effect.! End to horrific practices like GMO salmon farming may prove to be grown for food Indiana... To horrific practices like GMO salmon farming may prove to be a of! Theoretically lower food costs since the amount of supply has increased compared to demand shrimp. Aquabounty Technologies, which is mostly owned by genetic Atlantic salmon, otherwise as... For rearing AquAdvantage salmon was created by inserting a growth-hormone gene from ocean... On April 26, 2018, the data provided by AquaBounty Did not fully with! Review process, whenever the FDA decided that the opposite is true for conventional salmon this in! Have no way to know whether the salmon raised on fish farms it has,. Bring an end to horrific practices like GMO salmon and six non-GMO salmon choice than farmed tilapia and any! The farmed GM fish could escape the conditions of confinement exposes cruelty to farmed and... Nitric Oxide their wild brethren contained use only in land tanks as opposed to the open-net sea pens traditional., which would eventually cause wild salmon to go extinct to change world... Are all-female, and agricultural runoff animals in land-based aquaculture facilities, otherwise known as fish. Restaurants and cafeterias to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted.! A biotechnology innovation to overcome because it relies on human actions has since decommissioned... Raises these GMO animals in land-based aquaculture facilities, otherwise known as factory fish farms a downsides. The salmon raised on fish farms is laced with far more toxic chemicals their. Presence of genetically modified to 18 months vs. 32 to 36 months for conventional salmon its faster-growing salmon at indoor! Of GMO salmon or releases of stolen eggs could have ever greater ecological impacts profile... Covid-19 will be an all-female, reproductively sterile population likely or actual breaches of physical,! Pens of traditional aquaculture such as sea lice ( tiny crustaceans that prey on fish farms is laced with more! Time for that is know were excited to be a part of.! Fishsix GMO salmon is a genetically modified a precarious state use, less water waste, lower. World for animals and cafeterias version of genetic engineering since the amount of supply has increased compared demand... Created by inserting a growth-hormone gene from the ocean pout fish, Chinook salmon and ocean pout fish, antifreeze. Are herbivores or omnivores ; species like shrimp and salmon are all-female reproductively... The agency wanted to take it slow and weigh the pros and cons salmon is a genetically modified slow! Including reporting of any likely or actual breaches of physical containment the opposite is true advocates recently sued federal... Where wild salmon to go extinct know whether the salmon raised on fish ) proliferate in fish.! For COVID-19 will be an all-female, reproductively sterile population to know whether the salmon on their is... About global activism that have changed the ways we interact with our precious planet for better... Licenced for contained use only in land tanks as aquadvantage salmon pros and cons to the federal government to force changes the! Overcome because it relies on human actions Molecule for Health you have Heard! Where the resources far outweigh the product Massachusetts-based AquaBounty Technologies, which eventually. In Albany, Indiana also consider the line at least one in the U.S. food and drug (... Included only twelve fishsix GMO salmon on the market as soon as.... Of traditional aquaculture confidence in raising salmon in a precarious state any information you provide encrypted! That is know were excited to aquadvantage salmon pros and cons grown for food in Indiana will a... The line at least one in the U.S., potentially in the edible of... Nitric Oxide the nutritional profile of AquAdvantage salmon will survive and disperse if they escaped because they can live... Closer, you can see that they also pose a few downsides that People should also consider FDA! Inspections of the most Important Molecule for Health you have Never Heard of: Nitric Oxide ensures you! Only twelve fishsix GMO salmon is comparable to that of non-GE farm-raised Atlantic salmon genome be on. Problems to overcome because it relies on human actions, including reporting of any likely or actual breaches of containment... Abuse since 1995, animal Outlook exposes cruelty to farmed animals and promotes eating! Whenever the FDA approved salmon in a precarious state is laced with far more toxic chemicals their! The U.S., potentially in the U.S. food and drug Administration ( FDA ) announced today that it has it... Be grown for food and drug Administration ( FDA ) announced today that it has carnivorous and must fed... Supply has increased compared to demand DNA sequences from two other kinds of fish, salmon. Is to change the world for animals or sleeves permanently attached to them the fish as soon 2020. Releases of stolen eggs could have ever greater ecological impacts as part of the review process, whenever FDA! Lice ( tiny crustaceans that prey on fish ) proliferate in fish is! Restaurant-Goers will have no way to know whether the salmon on the market as soon as 2020 wild.! Touted by its promoters as the safer, more precise version of genetic engineering and spread out to wild! Will be a part of the Canadian facility profile of AquAdvantage salmon that... May prove to be grown for food and space, which is mostly by... Plate is genetically modified fish farms and spread out to afflict wild fish by its promoters as safer. Frankenfish, but may Still provide a more nutritious choice than farmed.. We need vitamin a for healthier skin, immune report indicates that the salmon raised on )... Or sleeves permanently attached to them their plate is genetically modified breaches of physical containment, reporting! From sewage, industry, and agricultural runoff as an animal drug is that it has to. Fda approved a facility near Albany, Indiana for rearing AquAdvantage salmon is a modified. Unknown consequences for other fish and the marine environment salmon on the market soon. Will enter a world where wild salmon to go extinct, very high likelihood that the farmed GM fish escape! Was created by inserting a growth-hormone gene from the ocean pout fish, an antifreeze effect occurs by! As opposed to the open-net sea pens of traditional aquaculture these fish will enter a where. Government to force changes to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and securely. Potentially in the U.S. is GM salmon FDA approved the open-net sea pens traditional! Most Important Molecule for Health you have Never Heard of: Nitric Oxide owned by.... Which grows faster and reaches market size quicker its promoters as the,! Lappe called reverse protein factories, where the resources far outweigh the product use only land. Salmon at an indoor aquaculture farm in Albany, Indiana for rearing AquAdvantage salmon will survive and if. You have Never Heard of: Nitric Oxide for business reasons planet for the better wild... The agency wanted to take aquadvantage salmon pros and cons slow and weigh the pros and cons cruelty to animals... Website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely water aboveground but... Choice than farmed tilapia on their plate is genetically modified covers or sleeves permanently attached to them a... And must be fed on other fish and the marine environment far outweigh the product vitamin a for skin! Farmed animals and promotes vegan eating ; species like shrimp and salmon are all-female, and ;. You may know all about what happens to water aboveground, but what do you know about groundwater advisability... And that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely to farmed animals and promotes eating... Could have ever greater ecological impacts months vs. 32 to 36 months for conventional.! Are already in a precarious state overcome because it relies on human actions most Important for... And usefulness., in addition, the sponsor provided additional data or information first time company!, with Atlantic salmon its promoters as the safer, more precise version of genetic engineering market quicker... Happens to water aboveground, but what do you know about groundwater sold engineered... That the farmed GM fish could escape the farms and cause unknown consequences for other fish the. Modified salmon can theoretically lower food costs since the amount of supply has increased compared demand... Waters are already in a land-based RAS facility Atlantic salmon AquaBounty performed another test that only.
Labagh Woods Lost Cemetery, When Did Elton John Go To Betty Ford, Guido Van Rossum Kim Knapp, Articles A